Introduction
When choosing a shower curtain liner, two popular options are fabric (like polyester) or PEVA plastic. But how do fabric and PEVA shower liners compare in terms of performance, durability, and overall benefits? This article examines the pros and cons of fabric vs PEVA shower liners to help you determine which material makes the better choice.
Is fabric or PEVA shower liner better?
Fabric shower liners offer advantages over PEVA:
- More aesthetically pleasing, coming in various colors, prints and fabric textures.
- Softer, cozier feel. Fabric retains heat better than plastic.
- Fabric can be machine washed to restore water repellency.
- Natural fabrics like cotton and bamboo are more eco-friendly.
- Fabrics like polyester have inherent mildew resistance.
However, PEVA offers:
- Cheaper cost over quality fabrics like polyester or nylon.
- Reliable waterproofing similar to vinyl, its plastic polymer base.
So PEVA wins for budget-friendly water protection, while fabric excels in style, feel and longevity.
Do fabric shower liners leak?
Quality heavy-weight fabric liners minimize leakage by:
- Using tightly woven, non-porous fabrics like polyester.
- Having sealed, reinforced seams to eliminate gaps.
- Incorporating weights/magnets along bottom hem for better cling.
- Featuring water-repellent coatings to bead water.
- Allowing thorough drying in between uses.
With the right fabric and design, leakage can be minimized, although still possible over time.
Is a PEVA shower curtain waterproof?
Yes, PEVA shower curtains are reliably waterproof thanks to their polyethylene plastic base, similar to vinyl. The vinyl acetate component allows the PE plastic to have a woven, fabric-like texture and flexibility. Combined, this makes PEVA curtains effectively waterproof while mimicking a cloth fabric appearance and drape.
Do fabric shower curtains need a liner?
For lightweight daily use, fabric curtains may suffice alone if:
- Made of moisture-wicking fabric like polyester.
- Coated with water repellent treatments.
- Allowed to fully dry between uses.
But for heavy splashing, pair fabric with a hidden vinyl backing liner for failsafe water protection.
Is it better to have a fabric shower curtain?
Fabric shower curtains have benefits over plastic:
- More aesthetics - colors, prints, textures
- Softer, cozier hand feel
- Longer lasting, more durable materials
- Machine washability to restore water resistance
- Better insulation against cold
- Reduced noisy sounds
The main disadvantage is most lack inherent waterproofness without a liner. Overall, fabric excels in styling, feel and convenience.
Conclusion
When choosing a shower liner, both fabric and PEVA have merits. PEVA offers assured waterproofness at an affordable cost. But fabric provides better aesthetics, comfort and longevity. For the best of both, pair a fashionable fabric curtain with a PEVA liner for decoration and protection