Introduction
When choosing a new shower curtain liner, two main options exist - traditional plastic/vinyl liners or today's fabric liner alternatives. But which performs better? Here we'll compare fabric vs plastic shower liners, analyzing the pros and cons of each to determine which material makes the better water barrier and bath accessory overall.
Is fabric or plastic shower liner better?
Plastic vinyl shower liners are cheap, ubiquitous and effective at containing water. But fabric shower liners offer advantages like:
- More aesthetically pleasing colors, prints and textures
- Softer hand feel and texture that matches decor better
- Increased durability from higher quality woven materials
- Ability to launder to restore water resistance
- Better insulation against cold in the bathroom
- Reduced noisy rustling sounds
- Customizable sizing and weighted hem options
If style and longevity are priorities, fabric liners excel. But plastics remain budget-friendly waterproofing.
Is it better to have a plastic or fabric shower liner?
Plastic vinyl shower liners are best for:
- Low cost and widespread availability
- Reliable water impenetrability when new
- Opacity to obscure shapes for privacy
Fabric shower liners are preferable for:
- Stylish colors, prints, and fabric textures
- Softer hand feel and drape
- Noise reduction - less plastic rustling
- Improved temperature insulation
- Machine-washability to maintain water resistance
- Customization - size, shape, weights, magnets
What is the best material for a shower curtain liner?
Top fabric choices include:
- Polyester - Mildew-resistant, durable, quick-drying
- Nylon - Extremely strong but still lightweight
- Microfiber - Dense weave prevents moisture absorption
- Treated cotton - Waterproof acrylic or silicone backing
For plastic:
- Vinyl - Most common and affordable water barrier
- PEVA - More durable alternative to vinyl
Do fabric shower curtains need a liner?
Lightweight daily fabrics may suffice alone if:
- Made of moisture-wicking polyester or microfiber
- Feature a water repellent coating like silicone
- Have well-sealed seams to prevent leakage points
- Allowed to fully dry between uses
For heavy splashing, pair fabric with a hidden vinyl backing liner for failsafe protection.
Do fabric shower liners mold?
With proper airflow and cleaning, fabric liners resist mold better than vinyl.
- Let fabric dry fully between showers
- Wash frequently in hot water
- Use antimicrobial sprays
- Replace fabric more often than plastic
Conclusion
Today's fabric shower curtain liners compete with plastic in terms of waterproof performance, while offering improved style, feel, and longevity. Focus on tightly woven, coated fabrics like polyester or nylon for optimal splash protection and convenience. Or use a fabric/plastic pair for the best of both options.